top of page

Why become a teacher?

há 7 dias
13 min de leitura

A young teacher on the outskirts of Lisbon teaches at two schools and gives private lessons at a study center. On weekends, she dresses up as a princess and entertains at birthday parties. She says she loves teaching. Her greatest inspiration was her primary school teacher. And she says this with her eyes shining with emotion and joy.



Sharpen small pencil

My dear Future:

I hope these words find you in good health, and I wish, here in the present, that in the future, planet Earth will be more balanced.


I am writing to you at the end of April 2022, the year in which the war in Ukraine began on February 24th.


I am writing to you to bring to your attention a seemingly minor issue, in the face of the tragedy of war or the multiple dramas that are affecting the planet and humanity: in Portugal there is a shortage of teachers.


I am very aware of this situation at my school, as the coordinator of the mathematics teachers. We have to perform immense juggling acts to manage to provide mathematics teachers for all our students.


On RTP, the public radio and television service in Portugal, a debate was broadcast on a program called "É ou não é" (Is it or isn't it), usually presented by Carlos Daniel, but this week it was presented by Ana Lourenço.


In the debate were Maria de Lurdes Rodrigues [i] , Emília Brederode dos Santos [ii] , Filinto Lima [iii] and Paulo Guinote.


What are the reasons for becoming a teacher?

To kick off the debate “What Future for Education?”, Ana Lourenço asked participants to present “one reason to be a teacher in Portugal today”.


Curiously, all the participants ended up avoiding the question, getting entangled in other considerations.


The question therefore remained for each of us, the 150,127 active teachers (4) or at least the many thousands who would be watching the debate. But the question is not just for teachers. It is a question that is posed to every Portuguese person or every politician.


The question continued to resonate in my mind, and I couldn't resist sharing a draft of an answer with you, my dear Future. This answer will serve to help me structure my own thoughts and reflect on the reasons for being a teacher.


It's worth starting by asking what reasons one should give to anyone for being whatever they want to be.


What are the reasons for becoming a journalist? For becoming a doctor? For becoming a carpenter?


When we talk about reasons for being whatever one is, we think, for example, of social status, that golden aura that seems to surround someone who practices certain professions.


We can talk about the respect that a professional inspires in the public.


We can talk about the remuneration someone can receive from practicing any profession. We can also talk about the security and stability that a profession can offer to those who practice it.


What these aspects have in common is what could be called "satisfaction"—satisfaction that comes from social status, respect, money, or security.


There is debate about whether a teaching career is appealing or not. The data says that quite simply it is not. Young people do not want to pursue this career. Those who are teachers, if they can, leave, and burnout rates are high, especially among older teachers [v] .


And why all this?


Isn't it noble and appealing to be responsible for the essential development of children and young people?


Isn't this personal development of students a guarantee for the future?


Didn't the pandemic and the resulting lockdown highlight the crucial importance of schools and teachers?




Do the Portuguese trust or respect teachers?

The study carried out by GFK [vi] for the Global Teacher Prize initiative in 2018 [vii] tells us that teachers are the professions most trusted by the Portuguese, after firefighters and doctors. But in terms of respectability they come in 5th place after firefighters, doctors, the military and the police. Teachers are trusted, but society considers that other professions are more respected.


Are teachers well paid?

In terms of remuneration, we know that teachers earn low salaries when compared to other graduates, or when considering the working hours that always exceed the 35 hours established as the official working schedule.


Is there job security in the teaching profession?

Job security for teachers is only achieved when they become permanent staff members at a school. Until then, they have a very precarious status. There are around 28,000 teachers, 27% of all teachers [viii] , for whom each start of the school year is a real game of Russian roulette. Many years pass before these teachers acquire the security of a permanent position. Sometimes only after 20 or more years of work.


Do teachers not advance in their careers?

Another issue that impacts remuneration is the way one progresses in their career. There's always the old reference to the armed forces and military hierarchy. One rises in rank through competence and training, and therefore receives higher pay. And not everyone reaches the rank of general. However, a teaching career has very specific characteristics. Teachers in a school all perform the same role and have the same functions: to teach and to facilitate learning, regardless of accumulated experience. There are no real hierarchies.


The failure to implement these appointments is linked to a policy of limiting the opening of vacancies in each school's staff, a process that seems aimed at saving money in the state budget each year. This is certainly legitimate, as teachers are the largest group of public employees: more than 150,000, as many as doctors and nurses combined. However, a career with obstacles to its advancement is, fundamentally, an injustice to those who perform such an important function.


Finally, Portugal trusts teachers, but doesn't respect them much, pays them poorly, and doesn't offer job security to a good percentage of these professionals. Meanwhile, it is considered by everyone to be a demanding profession. 76% of those surveyed in the GFK study never considered the possibility of becoming a teacher. [ix]


So how do we make this profession attractive, or at least ensure that the need for teachers is met?


Now, in truth, it's not about enticing people with benefits or privileges. On the contrary, it's about asking what conditions are necessary to enable them to perform the duties inherent in being a teacher of the children and young people of a country?

The assumption is that, given these conditions, practicing this profession becomes at least minimally appealing.


What about safety conditions, remuneration, scientific and teaching training? What about dignity?




What future for education, and under what conditions?

The answer can only be given if we delve into the meaning of education and the challenge of learning. What do students need to learn better? What characteristics should a teacher have to best contribute to good learning?


Every day I try to go to bed around 10 pm so I can get a good 8 hours of sleep. I get up around 6 am, do my morning routine, have a good breakfast, and then, at 8:15 am, I'm wide awake and in a good mood to face a class of 25 children. On weekends I need to rest and recharge.


At my school, I have classmates who show up in the morning fresh, cheerful, and full of energy. They are emotionally stable, go to the movies and the theater, are attentive to what is happening around them, and keep up-to-date through frequent reading.


The question to ask is: what conditions should be provided to a teacher so that they can reach this level? The answer is simple: career stability, security, and adequate remuneration with satisfactory progression.


But there is another aspect. The crucial issue is sometimes forgotten: for students to learn properly, it is necessary that the teacher has himself undergone an appropriate training and development process. This training not only leads to better performance with students, but also contributes to better results and greater satisfaction for the teacher himself.


Suspect #1 – Burnout and training

Therefore, suspicion arises (suspicion #1) that a significant portion of the frustration and disillusionment felt by teachers, leading to burnout, stems from the inadequate preparation they initially receive. Consider the history of teacher training in Portugal and observe the weaknesses in the training received by the majority of active teachers. Burnout doesn't just come from exhaustion. Perhaps it also stems from frustration, from the powerlessness of not being able to meet the service that society demands, whether due to a lack of teacher training or a shortage of resources in schools.

Suspect #2 – Ability to form

The participants in the RTP debate ended up concluding that there is sufficient capacity in Higher Education to train the teachers needed for the coming years. But the question remains whether Portugal has the adequate and sufficient know-how to train quality teachers. It is suspected that it does not (suspicion #2).


The debate included two researchers with extensive experience in higher education and two teachers with practical experience in schools. Curiously, two men were invited to speak about a profession where 78% are women [x] . An interesting tension hung in the air from the start, partly because Maria de Lurdes Rodrigues was one of the most controversial figures to have led the Ministry of Education this century. But perhaps there are other reasons. There is, in fact, a tension between the world of universities and the world of schools. As if the university had little knowledge of schools, and schools had little opportunity to access the reflections and conclusions of the research being produced.


Suspect #3 – An abyssal chasm

Every year I receive requests to respond to surveys related to master's or doctoral theses in the field of education. Not once has our school received the conclusions of these studies in which it participated. Nor do we know where to consult them. It is suspected (suspicion no. 3), therefore, that there is a gap between universities in the area of pedagogy and didactics.


Suspicion #4 – The failure of continuing education

If we talk about initial training, we must also talk about continuing education, where the suspicion arises (suspicion no. 4) that the current system for continuing teacher training does not yet meet the needs of this profession.


But, my dear Future, it's not just about having more or fewer teachers. It's about having an education system capable of developing in children and young people all the human capacities that each one has the potential for, and of ensuring that each child and each young person appropriates the immense patrimony of knowledge accumulated by humanity.

In this education system, teachers play a central role, but we can only offer "satisfaction" to a teacher if he or she is properly prepared to carry out their important mission.


5 challenges to face in education

More than analyses or reflections, it is necessary to define paths to follow to ensure that teachers fulfill their mission.


For just over a month now, there has been a new Minister of Education in Portugal.

(1) The first challenge is to change the rules for short-term hiring of teachers right away, a task that the new minister has already begun to carry out.


There are teachers who apply for short-term positions and receive such low pay that it's not even worth accepting the schedule, especially since they are far from home and have fixed expenses for accommodation and travel. The current solution involves a teacher teaching at two schools without truly being integrated into the school community. A teacher doesn't just teach classes. A teacher should be part of a larger team, be present at the school beyond class time, know the community where the school is located, and perform various tasks. Someone who enters the classroom and rushes out to get to another school cannot do this. Therefore, a school should be able to hire a teacher, even for short hours, and ensure that this teacher receives full pay, because there is no shortage of work in a school.


(2) It is necessary for teachers to gain stability by remaining in a school with contracts of more than one year.


(3) For those who need to be away from home, there is a lack of accommodation that could be provided by local authorities. If some municipalities invest in artistic residencies, why not in residences for teachers?


Regarding teacher training, there is much to be done. We have already discussed the gap between universities and primary and secondary schools.


(4) First, we need to ensure that we have funding for research in the field of didactics and pedagogy and that we have research centers in these areas.


(5) Next, it is necessary to understand if there is good coordination between universities and schools. Those in schools need to be aware of new discoveries in the field of pedagogy. When we talk about innovation, we talk about technology and information technology. But we cannot forget that the human being continues to be formed by a brain that plays an important role in the learning process. And it is this brain, embedded in a child's body, that is at the center of the entire learning process; it is this brain and this body that needs to undertake a developmental journey in various aspects. And any and all innovation should aim to find new and better ways to promote the much-desired learning.



Central challenge: everyone learns

(6) Because there is a challenge that has not yet been fully met: how to ensure that everyone can learn.


If we travel back 60 years, we would find a school that focused on teaching a small percentage of students. Those who learned, congratulations! Those who didn't learn, too bad, they were condemned to professions reserved for illiterates.


The small percentage of students who learned managed to achieve this goal because they already possessed well-developed abilities. The challenge in Portugal, however, is precisely to ensure that 99% of children and young people can learn, and to achieve this they must develop their abilities as much as possible. And that, my dear Future, is a profound mystery.


Imagine if a decree were to define which antibiotics or anti-inflammatory drugs should be prescribed for each medical situation. That would obviously make no sense. It is technical and scientific training that enables a doctor to diagnose and decide which treatment should be followed. In education, however, it is legislation that "prescribes" the actions of teachers and the functioning of schools. One might ask why?


Suspicion #5 – Who doesn't trust teachers?

According to Helena Peralta [xi] , the German curriculum in secondary education had 5 pages in 1974/75, but in 1983 it increased to 25 pages and in 2005 it came in an old publication with 90 pages. One might ask why? It is suspected (suspicion no. 5) that there is no trust in teachers and, as such, the work of teachers must be very tightly controlled, with great detail, in programs approved by ministerial decree. It is also considered that it is by decree-law that teachers should be told how to act in schools.


Rebuilding trust in teachers may require different models of teacher training.


But between the published legislation, containing guidelines for oversight, and the teaching practices in schools across the country, there is another old tension.


From the perspective of the governing body, there is a desire to implement new ways of building the school, which come with the weight of legality and compliance with the law. However, there is a lack of training that could awaken and enrich teachers' perspectives on a world that pulsates and moves forward, "like a colorful ball in the hands of a child."


Schools are isolated islands where the intense demands on teachers exhaust them and deprive them of time to think and feel the winds blowing from all corners of society and the world. Here, collaboration between universities and schools, from primary to secondary levels, would be a solution.


Suspicion #6 – Universality of the school

Some new political parties accuse those who have been in power for many years in Portugal of failing to promote the desired economic and social development of the country. They cite international rankings and mention the Baltic and other Eastern European countries, whose economic indicators have surpassed those of Portugal. They propose as a solution the measures typical of a certain economic liberalism, highlighting Latvia and the Czech Republic. In truth, the secret of these and many other countries may not lie in liberalization. Consider the fact that these countries have invested in education for many decades, or even centuries. Remember that the Marquis of Pombal wore shorts when Prussia had already decreed compulsory schooling in 1717. Therefore, there is a suspicion (suspicion no. 6) that the much-desired development of a territory depends on the education of its inhabitants.


Finally, my dear Future, I return to Ana Lourenço's question: " one reason to be a teacher in Portugal today".


A young teacher on the outskirts of Lisbon teaches at two schools and gives private lessons at a study center. On weekends, she dresses up as a princess and entertains at birthday parties. She says she loves teaching. Her greatest inspiration was her primary school teacher. And she says this with her eyes shining with emotion and joy.


Suspect #7 – Perhaps a better world

Perhaps the answer to Ana Lourenço lies in the teary eyes of this young teacher.

The answer is therefore simple: the reason for being a teacher is the pleasure one gets from feeling that one contributes to the growth and discovery of a world by hundreds of students through the knowledge one has accumulated. Through this acquired knowledge and developed skills, it is suspected (suspicion #7) that the world can become a little better.


The 7 suspicions of education

We therefore have 7 suspects:

  • Suspicion #1 - It is suspected that the frustration felt by teachers, which makes this profession unappealing, stems from a very weak initial teacher training.

  • Suspicion #2 - It is suspected that this weak training comes from universities that lack the know-how to properly train future teachers.

  • Suspicion #3 – And this lack of know-how will not arise precisely because there is a gap between universities and schools.

  • Suspicion #4 - There is also suspicion that the ongoing teacher training system is not the most appropriate.

  • Suspicion #5 - It is suspected, however, that the result of this deficient teacher training leads to a lack of confidence in teachers on the part of the supervisory authority.

  • Suspicion #6 - This situation leads to the suspicion that without a solid education managed by well-prepared teachers, the further development of any country is compromised, making a truly universal school system necessary.

  • Suspicion #7 - Finally, it is suspected that good teachers, well-prepared, emotionally secure, and with fair and dignified remuneration, would be the basis for the good preparation of children and young people who will contribute to a better world.

The School and Peace

During the 1990s, schools in Portugal encouraged children to think about peace and environmental issues. The results are evident. This work of raising awareness for peace was so well developed that it is with astonishment and surprise that we discover such great disregard for these issues on the other side of Europe.


In Moscow, my dear Future, even next to the ancient Cathedral of St. Basil, someone seems not to know what peace is and how important it is.


It's fair to say that Putin went to a different school than the many that exist on this side of Europe.


A friendly hug

Eduardo Rui Alves

(Happy teacher of 3000 students over 10,000 hours of classes in 30 years of profession)

[i] Former Minister of Education between 2005 and 2009.

[iii] President of the National Association of Directors of Groups and Public Schools, https://andaep.com/orgaos-sociais accessed on 26/4/2022.

[viii] Ibid. 4. [ix] Ibid. page 22. [x] Ibid. 4 [xi] Maria Helena Peralta holds a PhD in Educational Sciences, in the area of Curriculum Development and Assessment, and a Master's degree in German Literature. She is a retired assistant professor at the Institute of Education of the University of Lisbon. She has developed and continues to develop research activities in Curriculum Development, Assessment and Didactics of Foreign Languages.

 
 
 

Comentários


  • Vimeo ícone social
  • YouTube ícone social
LogoPessoal Rodapé Branco.png

© 2026 por Eduardo Rui Alves.

bottom of page